Browser download confirmation window position [Resolved! Windows bug]

bphlpt

A lowly staff member
Staff member
This is a weird thing.

I have all of my browsers set to open a confirmation window for every download, to be able to change where the file is downloaded to, and to be able to change the name of the downloaded file if necessary.

All of a sudden, I mean I was downloading things with my browser, and between one download and the next, the confirmation window decided to ALWAYS open positioned in the top left corner of the browser window. I am used to being able to move it around on the screen and resize it if I want, and the next time I download something, it always remembers its dimensions and location where I used it last. Now, it remembers its dimensions, but it always opens in the browser's top left corner. It must be a Window's setting, because it affects four different browsers I've checked - Waterfox, Firefox, Opera, and Chrome. I can change the size and location of the browser window, even make it very, very small, and if I download anything, the confirmation window is positioned in the browser's top left corner, even if the confirmation window is bigger than the browser window, no matter where on the screen the browser window is located.

How can I change this behavior? When I try to do a web search, it thinks I mean, "What location do I want the downloaded file stored?" rather than, "What location do I want the download confirmation window located?"

Does anybody have better google-foo than I do today?

Yes, I've run CCleaner, rebooted the machine, etc. And this particular symptom is the only one I've noticed.

EDIT: The browser window remembers its size and position, it's just the pop-up confirmation window I'm having an issue with.

EDIT 2: And to be clear, I'm not talking about the window that gives you the choice to execute/play or to save the file (that one works correctly), I'm talking about the next window you get where you can choose where to save the file and rename it if desired. I can resize that window if I want, but I can't move it. Or rather, I can move it, but next time it's back to the top left corner.



EDIT 3:
Resolved! Verified Windows bug. See here - https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us...f-screen/2b7112a7-162c-412d-97ec-7b0c09a6e828

WTH????? That's it. Switch scaling off and on and the issue goes away and comes back. (I use 150% with my 4K monitor)

Very, very strange, and I don't know why it only seems to effect those particular pop-ups and why it used to work and now it doesn't.

And of course it is a Windows bug that's been verified for over three years and MS hasn't bothered to fix it. Typical.
 
Last edited:
That is weird. I assume you right-clicked desktop > Personalize Extra > Explorer Icon Refresh or else rebooted? Do you have a multi-monitor setup? Or do you use display scaling?

I can't think of anything else atm, and I agree that's a hard one to Google.
 
Completely rebooted, single monitor, yes to scaling, but I always have with this monitor, and no problems since I've had the monitor. And why change behavior between one download and the next? I'm living with it, it's just an annoyance, after all, but still...
 
You're right, @Glenn. "Position" might help my google-fu. But I'm afraid that the suggestions in that article are more appropriate for app windows rather than a pop-up save-as window. But I tried clicking, shift-clicking, and double-clicking in both top corners anyway to no effect.

I found this - https://www.jeroentielen.nl/explaining-the-bagsbagmru-registry-tree-trying/, referring to this key - HKEY_CURRENT_USER/SOFTWARE/Microsoft/Windows/CurrentVersion/Explorer/ComDlg32/CIDSizeMRU, which seems promising. First, I exported Computer\HKEY_CURRENT_USER\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Explorer\ComDlg32\CIDSizeMRU, for safety, then I found which numbered key refers to Waterfox. When I delete that key, when I go back to Waterfox and download something, a replacement key is created. But I can't do what the article suggests, changing the permission for the key. I could only see that I could change the permission at the CIDSizeMRU level, and I didn't think that was appropriate.

Besides, the name CIDSizeMRU kind of implies the size of the window, not its position, doesn't it?

I haven't found out what info is stored in that key, and if there is any way to tell it to use the previous position, but that's what I need to figure out how to do.

There are other keys in the area that by name seem to be of interest.

Computer\HKEY_CURRENT_USER\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Explorer\ComDlg32\OpenSavePidlMRU -- is one, but the contained keys are by file type, rather than by application used

Computer\HKEY_CURRENT_USER\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Explorer\CIDOpen --- and --- Computer\HKEY_CURRENT_USER\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Explorer\CIDSave -- both appear to be dead ends.

But I'm just wandering around and exploring. Does anyone know of a good, readable explanation of all the keys in that area of the registry that explains their format and purpose?

EDIT: This looks promising, but not everything applies to Win 10, since it references a thing or two that I don't have.

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/dlgbox/open-and-save-as-dialog-boxes
 
Last edited:
Nirsoft GuiPropView was suggested - https://www.nirsoft.net/utils/gui_prop_view.html

GuiPropView found the window. See pic.
View attachment 2379

Verified it was the right window and that it could be moved with the command:

K:\G\Software\Nirsoft\guipropview-x64_v1.30>GUIPropView.exe /Action SetPos 1024 100 "Process:C:\Program Files\Waterfox\waterfox.exe" Class:#32770 Title:Enter*

I still don't see anywhere I can specify that it should - "reopen window at previous position"

I can resize the window, and it remembers that, but not the previous position.

It also remembers the previous download location, seemingly everything except position.
 
Only one browser at a time, these days usually Waterfox, but when the weird behavior started, I checked the others, trying to decide if it was confined to one browser, or a more generalized windows behavior. Since it is the same behavior in multiple browsers, and not just chrome or mozilla based, I am assuming it is a Windows solution that I need.

No, it doesn't depend on what else is on the screen, where the browser window is located, or what the size of the browser window is. The pop-up save-as window will always be located at the top left of the browser window.
 
All browsers I currently have installed exhibit the same behavior. First try with whatever browser you currently have installed, Then try with Waterfox. The behavior should be the same. It used to be that when the save-as window popped up, I could reposition and resize the window, and change the folder where I wanted to save the file, even change the name of the file if I wanted to, before I clicked "save", and the next time I tried to save a file, the save-as window would reopen with the same position, size, and save-to location. Now, it remembers everything except the previous screen position.

Downloading a series of files from the repo is an example. Download one file, positioning the save-as window as you like, and when you save a second file, the save-as window should open up where you last had it. Mine used to. Now, it doesn't.
 
It is weird BP, the normal default behavior is when you move the save windows and close it, then save anything else it'll open in the last spot you close it... Not sure where it saves, but I'll get back to you after I use regshot to see if I can find it.
 
Here's an example using Pale Moon. First, I download one file and reposition the save-as window:

View attachment 2380

When I download the second file:

View attachment 2381

the save-as window is in the top left corner of the browser.

By the way, I just realized the exact same behavior is also happening when I clicked "Upload a File" here. The "File Upload" window is also ALWAYS in the top left corner of the browser. Another clue!
 
I know this fixes it (or at least lets you move it, because I tested it and it was able to move my window back to a different position when I ran it after saving the new position), so if your still having issues it is NOT the positioning system, it's either the reg key is locked/don't have permission, or your explorer's common dialog is corrupted either by a patch/crash or version mismatch after an update.
 
Running this file will move it, but my other fix should have fixed it for you already.
 
Sorry, @Glenn, no dice. Neither "fix" made any difference whatsoever. I even rebooted multiple times before and after applying the fix. I can always move the window, but the next download whether I restarted the browser or not, rebooted or not, or applied the fix or not, the save-as window is back at the browser's to left corner.

It just doesn't remember the previous position.
 
go into the registry and see if the value changes when I pointed to, lets see if it's a retrieval issue or what, because like I said, I confirmed that this registry location IS what stores the position, so if your isn't being read, you have bigger issues going on than the position of the dialog, the save dialog screen position isn't set in any other stop on the operating system, so if your moving the save dialog and the saved MRU isn't updated, then it's a system wide corruption at a core API call, so you'll not fix it without a sfc or a total reinstall.
 
Not sure if your one of those kinds of people who run registry cleans, but this is also a side effect of them, which is why I don't include any tools to do that anymore, they always break more than they fix... that said, if it's already broken, run a reg cleaner to see if that helps, can't get much worse than the inability for built in windows calls not able to read/write to the registry.
 
If you want us to solve this, it would take a image of the system disk shared online for us to run, so probably not worth it :P but if it helps you sleep at night... maybe?
 
I found this - https://www.jeroentielen.nl/explaining-the-bagsbagmru-registry-tree-trying/, referring to this key - HKEY_CURRENT_USER/SOFTWARE/Microsoft/Windows/CurrentVersion/Explorer/ComDlg32/CIDSizeMRU, which seems promising. First, I exported Computer\HKEY_CURRENT_USER\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Explorer\ComDlg32\CIDSizeMRU, for safety, then I found which numbered key refers to Waterfox. When I delete that key, when I go back to Waterfox and download something, a replacement key is created.

So a new key is written in CIDSizeMRU whenever any browser triggers the save-as dialog. The save-as window dimensions are saved, as is the last saved location, just not the previous window position. Same for the file-upload window. A new key is created there when a file is uploaded, but if you move the file-upload window before you upload the file, the file-upload window position is NOT saved, so when the file-upload window is opened again, the dimensions and file location info have been saved, but the window position has not been saved.

So for both of these pop-ups, the key is created and saved, and apparently used, since the dimensions are remembered, but the position is not saved.

I've confirmed that the size is remembered by uploading a file, resize and move the window in the process, try to upload a second file, the window is back in the top left corner, but it DID remember the new size. Delete the registry key and try to upload a third file, it's still in the top left, but now the window is back to its default size. In all cases, the file location is remembered.

My opinion, based strictly on behavior, is that the CIDSizeMRU key remembers the size/dimension of the window, the position is kept somewhere else, and the file location is kept in some third location. Do you know where we can find documentation to confirm whether this is true or not?

EDIT: No, this is really just an annoyance, and only because I got used to the other behavior.
 
I did a sfc (no errors found), chkdsk, and ran CCleaner Technician (including its registry cleaner), with reboots in-between, to no avail. No change in behavior.
 
I already said the fix.reg contains the position, I moved it on my PC, saved it, confirmed it reopened in the other position, closed it, ran the registry fix and when I opened the window again it was in the original position it was when I exported the registry.

So the size and position is kept there.

I do remember if you resize it holding the shift key in the size you make it is set permanently, meaning if you regshot that you may get a clue to your permanent position as well :)
 
It does put the exe name at the top in binary format, so the one I sent you had chrome.exe at the top, but it was stored as Key name 2 - if yours was different to 2 then it may have been duplicated, which is why I sent the one that deleted the entire key tree to start fresh
 
Last edited:
For me, for whatever reason, the size/dimensions are saved, but not the position, shift key or not.

I wish I knew the format of the key itself. When you "modify" the key, you can read the app that created it, but not the position and/or size info.
 
There is talk of the bug you explain (or similar (size not position problems) occurring in a Windows 10 update from 2021, but it has been fixed in newer updates, if your saying it was working then wasn't, maybe the bug is back and your the only one who has that update installed? meaning I wont be able to help with it any more than I have and that the solution will have to come from installing a MS update, or uninstalling one :)

This is the only thing on the internet that had any mention of the layout of this key:
https://www.tenforums.com/software-apps/15714-save-dialog-resize-problem.html

All the other code is purged from the internet, I found links to examples on Microsoft, but they are dead links, You can play with way back machine, but I am confident that it's a issue with the OS state and nothing you've done. especially after I found that it was something that happened to others in Windows 10 and theirs was update repaired.
 
Thanks, but I had already seen that link. Don't worry about it, you did way more than enough. Like I said, the only reason I even noticed it was that I was used to the previous behavior. It's not a problem, just an annoyance. :) You had done miracles fixing my issue with losing the ability to add a new text document, so I just hoped for another miracle. Many thanks for all of your efforts. :)
 
Back
Top